Both were good settings for the play because they both pointed out the ways of life in the time period that the director wanted to display the film. Why is the zeffirelli verzion of romeo and juliet better. Franco zeffirelli and baz luhrmann go headtohead as francesca. Similarities between zeffirelli and luhrmann version of. Easy to relate to and generally keeps students attention better than the zefirelli version. Luhrmann has cleverly taken the play and enacted it in a way that includes all the main elements of shakespeares version of the story, combined with the elements of a modern action film. Radio, magazine and live event operations will resume shortly. A wide variety of literature, despite how renowned, is susceptible to great alterations that may change the entire meaning of the work, such as romeo and juliet. I liked the film directed by zeffirelli better because in luhrmann s film, everything was too modern. Franco zefferelli, however, created his film in 1970, starring leonardo whitting and olivia hussey, focusing on how well the actors played the part of the. Modern adaption took away the purity guns juliet and romeo are a lot older, therefore theres less youthful love violence overwhelms the true meaning of the play. The two texts are set in completely contrasting social and historical contexts of elizabethan england to southern california in verona beach.
Analysis the tragedy of romeo and juliet by william shakespeare is considered by many the greatest love stories ever written. Zeffirellis film essay help high quality essay examples. Zeffirelli vs luhrmann romeo and juliet essay artscolumbia. Why is the zeffirelli verzion of romeo and juliet better than the luhrmann. Zeffirelli s is set in the 16th century, at the time when the screenplay would have first been written whereas luhrmann has set his film in modern time but still using the shakespearian language. Here are the best, and most noteworthy, versions of romeo and juliet that can help you study and better understand the play romeo and juliet. Comparing zeffirellis fight scene with shakespeares text.
Romeo and juliet zeffirelli vs luhrmann essay 586 words. Romeo and juliet is probably the greatest romantic tragedy ever written. Romeo and juliet, i decided to compare the two and say which one. Baz luhrmann and franco zeffirelli portrayed the film romeo and juliet in very different ways. Comparing the opening scene of the franco zeffirelli and baz luhrmann film versions of romeo and juliet comparing the opening scene of the franco zeffirelli and baz luhrmann film versions of romeo and juliet both directors present their interpretation of the epic tale of love, reflecting their attitudes towards play and playwright. He kept the italian theme running the whole way through and picked actors with a certain look which worked well. Comparison paragraph between franco zeffirelli and baz luhrmann. Baz luhrmann and franco zefirelli are two directors who have made this classic play into film. The baz luhrmanns 1996 adaptation of the play, staring leonardo dicaprio and claire danes, presents a modern day adaptation of the play, being set in present day at the time verona beach in the united states. As i set up the projector and film, students will take out their movie worksheet, which they started to complete last class, while watching the zeffirelli movie. From the films production design to the costumes, the 1996 version outperformed franco zeffirellis romeo and juliet due to luhrmann taking a more entertaining and modern approach to the famous play. The films of franco zeffirelli versus baz luhbrmanns version of romeo and juliet two films, both alike in content, set in fair verona, where the directors laid out their scene, one created by franco zeffirelli in 1968 and the other by baz luhbrmann in 1996. It has been retold many different times in both written and film text and it is effective and timeless throughout the use of many techniques. Romeo and juliet balcony scene comparison the jiblog.
These alterations of the script by luhrmann made the film more like a modern drama and considerably different to the zefferelli version. Both the luhrmann and the zeffirelli versions of the shakespearian play, romeo and juliet, have common scenes. Compare and contrast the methods used by zeffirelli and luhrmann. The differences between the 1968 and 1996 versions of romeo. In this episode, we discuss two modern film adaptations of romeo and juliet. If you compare this to shakespeares version than you really do feel that there is something missing. Two men, named franco zeffirelli and baz luhrmann, loved the tragedy so much that. Zeffirelli s version is closer to the play in scenery and costume, but luhrmann s version has a very unique juxtaposition that brings romeo and juliet into modern day.
The two movies had a lot in common, but at the same time they both had many differences. Romeo and juliet, one of the best love stories of all time, was written by the world famous author shakespeare, in the early 1600s. Romeo and juliet zeffirelli vs luhrmann term paper romeo and juliet, one of the best love stories of all time, was written by the world famous. The zeffirelli film was definitely a more accurate interpretation. Luhrmann briefly but successfully achieves what the whole film is after. Overall i think that the zeferelli film was very true the text and kept. My class studies the play using zeffirelli and then we watch luhrmann at the end of the unit for comparison. They are buying, selling, and interacting with each other.
Zeffirelli s film really shows what it was like back in the 14th century. In the zeffirelli version, the balcony scene was where romeo climbed up to her, and they just basically made out for a while, but in the luhrmann version romeo goes near her balcony but she comes down to him and they fall in the pool where they kiss but the vibe there is much more affectionate than the old version. We are going to watch a couple of scenes from the balcony scene through the fight scene in the 1960 and 1990 movie versions of the play. Romeo and juliet baclony comparison luhrmann vs zeffirelli.
At the same time, the luhrmanns version, shot as a blockbuster, concentrates upon modern times and can be fully decoded only in the historical context of the late xx century. There are some very obvious differences including the intended audience, the setting, the place and the timing of the play. There were also many differences that were quite noticeable between the original play and its two interpretations. This morning we are going to watch the older version. Zefferelli s film remains faithful to shakespeares original play, whereas luhrmann made a more modern version of it.
Baz luhrmann created his movie in 1997 with leonardo di caprio and claire danes taking the lead roles, he used young and popular, successful actors, to ensure the film s marketability. Which film production of romeo and juliet do you prefer. The cast is almost uniformly excellent im especially fond of pat heywoods nurse and the direction hardly ever puts a foot wrong. Zeffirelli looks great, having been filmed in italian renaissance locations and in authentically colourful costumes. Romeo and juliet movie comparison essay 2469 words. As i start the movie, they will prepare themselves to take notes. Romeo and juliet luhrmann and zeffirelli film comparison essay. The characters were using security cameras and dressed in modern day clothing. Baz luhrmann romeo and juliet death scene essay example. All three moviesnovel are amazing they all have their differences and their similarities but to pick a winner zeffirelli with its amazing traditionaldramatic scenes and dialogue that seemed to beat both the graphic novel and luhrmann movie. Baz luhrmanns film romeo and juliet, sample of essays. Get an answer for how do i compare baz luhrmann s and franco zeffirelli s versions of romoe and juliet. Despite the contrast of the two settings, both texts explore the external conflict which stemmed from the family. The fact that the film was made in the 1960s makes it even more appealing to the older generations as it was made when they were young and.
Baz luhrmann s kaleidoscopic film adaptation of romeo and juliet, while often leaving much to be desired from the two main actors in the way of delivery, presents a fascinating modern interpretation of the 16th century drama. Romeo and juliet luhrmann and zeffirelli film comparison. Of course, it cuts quite a lot of the play, but i cant criticise it more than very mildly for that. Therefore, i think that it was a more authentic portrayal of shakespeares famous play. Comparing the luhrmann and zeffirelli versions of romeo and juliet romeo and juliet is a play by shakespeare written in the sixteen century. Similarties and differences between romeo and juliet. Luhrmann misses out paris and the page in the fight, he basically misses out the fight scene. In 1968 zeffirelli directed his version of romeo and juliet. Romeo and juliet zeffirelli vs luhrmann freebooksummary.
In 1968, franco zeffirelli created what many consider to be the definitive. Compare and contrast the methods used by zeffirelli and. And when a tropical storm at the beach mirrors the action in its fury, mr. First, in the zeffirelli production 1968, the setting was at evening with romeo behind an overgrown garden and juliet upstairs in what appeared to be an old hillside stone villa. Romeo and juliet zeffirelli vs luhrmann, sample of essays. Luhrmann so valentines day has come and gone, and for the holidays, i usually watch movies that have to do with the holiday, watching horror movies in october and christmas movies in december and such. Franco zeffirelli s 1968 film, starring olivia hussey as juliet, and baz luhrmann s 1996 modern dress film starring leonardo dicaprio and claire danes as the starcrossed lovers. Comparison paragraph between franco zeffirelli and baz.
David ansen, film critic, describes it as alternately enrapturing and exhausting, brilliant and gliba romeo and. After the fight, in luhrmann s version, romeo is in a trashy part of town. Comparing zeffirelli and luhrmanns versions of romeo. This symbolizes his feelings over rosaline, the girl he loves. Romeo and juliet a comparecontrast essay comparing the. In the case of romeo and juliet, franco zeffirelli and baz luhrmann s film are different in many ways even though they are based on the same play. The films of franco zeffirelli versus baz luhbrmanns version of romeo and juliet. This exam paper sets out to analyse and compare the film adaptations of the italian. Including this may have made the end more dramatic and probably better than the one he used. Instead of going for a traditional approach, the luhrmann film went for an all out modern approach, which in turn didnt match up well with the traditional script. There are many things that make the balcony scenes in both the franco zeffirelli and the baz luhrmann productions so prolific. How do i compare baz luhrmanns and franco zeffirellis. Baz luhrmann s film romeo and juliet includes everything shakespeare intended in his play.
Romeo and juliet has been a popular story for over 400 years, either by the play written by shakespeare, or a poem written earlier than that. Franco zeferelli did the film in a very traditional way. Also, in the luhrmann version, the action begins with glimpses of the city and we see billboards, lots of cars, and people. Romeo and juliet zeffirelli and luhrmann the two main film interpretations of shakespeare s romeo and juliet are zeffirellis, made in 1968, and luhrmanns, made in 1997. While we watch, students will compare and contrast the movie with shakespeares play. Zeffirelli vs luhrmann romeo and juliet essay example for. Comparing shakespeares play to luhrmanns romeo and juliet. In the case of romeo and juliet, franco zeffirelli and baz luhrmanns film are different in many ways even though they are based on the same play. This class we are going to watch the same scenes in luhrmann s version and compare them, both to the other movie and to the play itself. The zeffirelli version took place in the city of verona. Shakespeares romeo and juliet is a play based on love, hate, tragedy and sacrifice.
Although true to the text through out zeffirellis ending wasnt true enough and took away the real meaning to the end of the story. Overall it seems that zeffirelli is the one to win,with his 1968 version of romeo and juliet the movie. The most popular and wellknown scene of romeo and juliet is the balcony scene where romeo and juliet first declare their love for each other. Trailer romeo and juliet trailer 2 20 hailee steinfeld, paul giamatti movie hd duration. One of the main differences between the two films, apart from the time set, is the opening scenes. Both movies told the tragic tale of two starcrossed lovers that were held apart by fate. From the films production design to the costumes, the 1996 version outperformed franco zeffirellis romeo and juliet due to luhrmann taking a more. Romeo and juliet baz luhrmann franco zeffirelli prologue. Study help film versions adaptations of shakespeares plays and other works have been featured in nearly 500 films andor videos worldwide. Zefirellis romeo and juliet is a true shakespearean movie of all times, as it combines historicism with timelessness of ideas and concepts introduced by shakespeare. Luhrmann only shows shots fired between the montagues and the capulets and a bit of confusion before prince comes into the scene in a helicopter. Can you compare the zeffirelli and luhrmann versions of. Romeo and juliet director showdown franco zeffirelli vs baz luhrmann vs a new film version of shakespeares most famous tragedy hits the silver screen today.
Franco zeffirelli and baz luhrmanns romeo and juliet. Most of the scenes in the film are portrayed in different ways although there are some similarities. Comparing zeffirelli and luhrmanns versions of romeo and. That makes shakespeare the most filmed playwright of all time. The films of franco zeffirelli versus baz luhbrmanns. This is a film comparison chart for the two film versions of romeo and juliet. The film by franco zeffirelli, in 1968, does a better job reenacting the play in a motion picture than the film made by baz luhrmann, in 1996, because the setting, costumes and characterization. Comparing the luhrmann and zeffirelli versions of romeo. One is the 1968 version which starred leonard whiting as romeo and olivia hussey as juliet and directed by franco zeffirelli which i have talked about in a previous blog and the 1996 version which starred leonardo dicaprio and claire danes and was directed by baz luhrmann. This shows that both the zeffirelli and luhrmann version are similar because the marketplace in the zeffirelli version is very busy with people and much activity.
121 444 839 1052 907 425 380 228 1133 1271 7 859 239 611 1508 959 527 163 189 1291 19 508 1594 1068 364 969 418 847 1654 630 27 55 1003 1376 849 1381 12 808 544 1098 113 74 1473 529